Informing pandemic response in the face of uncertainty. An evaluation of the U.S. COVID-19 Scenario Modeling Hub.
Howerton E., Contamin L., Mullany LC., Qin M., Reich NG., Bents S., Borchering RK., Jung S-M., Loo SL., Smith CP., Levander J., Kerr J., Espino J., van Panhuis WG., Hochheiser H., Galanti M., Yamana T., Pei S., Shaman J., Rainwater-Lovett K., Kinsey M., Tallaksen K., Wilson S., Shin L., Lemaitre JC., Kaminsky J., Hulse JD., Lee EC., McKee C., Hill A., Karlen D., Chinazzi M., Davis JT., Mu K., Xiong X., Pastore Y Piontti A., Vespignani A., Rosenstrom ET., Ivy JS., Mayorga ME., Swann JL., España G., Cavany S., Moore S., Perkins A., Hladish T., Pillai A., Toh KB., Longini I., Chen S., Paul R., Janies D., Thill J-C., Bouchnita A., Bi K., Lachmann M., Fox S., Meyers LA., UT COVID-19 Modeling Consortium None., Srivastava A., Porebski P., Venkatramanan S., Adiga A., Lewis B., Klahn B., Outten J., Hurt B., Chen J., Mortveit H., Wilson A., Marathe M., Hoops S., Bhattacharya P., Machi D., Cadwell BL., Healy JM., Slayton RB., Johansson MA., Biggerstaff M., Truelove S., Runge MC., Shea K., Viboud C., Lessler J.
Our ability to forecast epidemics more than a few weeks into the future is constrained by the complexity of disease systems, our limited ability to measure the current state of an epidemic, and uncertainties in how human action will affect transmission. Realistic longer-term projections (spanning more than a few weeks) may, however, be possible under defined scenarios that specify the future state of critical epidemic drivers, with the additional benefit that such scenarios can be used to anticipate the comparative effect of control measures. Since December 2020, the U.S. COVID-19 Scenario Modeling Hub (SMH) has convened multiple modeling teams to make 6-month ahead projections of the number of SARS-CoV-2 cases, hospitalizations and deaths. The SMH released nearly 1.8 million national and state-level projections between February 2021 and November 2022. SMH performance varied widely as a function of both scenario validity and model calibration. Scenario assumptions were periodically invalidated by the arrival of unanticipated SARS-CoV-2 variants, but SMH still provided projections on average 22 weeks before changes in assumptions (such as virus transmissibility) invalidated scenarios and their corresponding projections. During these periods, before emergence of a novel variant, a linear opinion pool ensemble of contributed models was consistently more reliable than any single model, and projection interval coverage was near target levels for the most plausible scenarios (e.g., 79% coverage for 95% projection interval). SMH projections were used operationally to guide planning and policy at different stages of the pandemic, illustrating the value of the hub approach for long-term scenario projections.