Cookies on this website

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you click 'Accept all cookies' we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies and you won't see this message again. If you click 'Reject all non-essential cookies' only necessary cookies providing core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility will be enabled. Click 'Find out more' for information on how to change your cookie settings.

A first-of-its kind randomised controlled trial compared two different antitoxin treatments for tetanus. A comparison of human and equine intramuscular antitoxin in adults found that intramuscular equine antitoxin is safe and effective for treating tetanus in adults. Addition of additional intrathecal (spinal) antitoxin does not add any benefit compared to treatment with intramuscular antitoxin alone.

Dr Lam Minh Yen, Senior Study Doctor at OUCRU, leads a workshop for adult patients recovering tetanus. Tetanus has been one of the components of OUCRU-HTD research programme for over 20 years.
Dr Lam Minh Yen, Senior Study Doctor at OUCRU, leads a workshop for adult patients recovering tetanus. Tetanus has been one of the components of OUCRU-HTD research programme for over 20 years.

This joint study carried out by the Oxford University Clinical Research Unit (OUCRU) and the Hospital for Tropical Diseases in Ho Chi Minh City has important implications for the treatment of tetanus, especially in low-resource settings.

Intramuscular antitoxin is recommended for the treatment of tetanus. The study found no evidence of increased adverse events in those treated with equine antitoxin compared to human antitoxin.

Equine antitoxin is cheaper and, in many countries, more easily available than human antitoxin. This study’s findings have shown that intramuscular equine antitoxin is safe, particularly where human antitoxin is unavailable.

Tetanus toxin acts within the central nervous system, where there is limited penetration of peripherally administered antitoxin; thus, intrathecal (spinal) antitoxin administration was thought to improve clinical outcomes compared with intramuscular injection. The study found that intrathecal injection, an invasive procedure, did not substantially reduce the requirement for mechanical ventilation in adults with tetanus.

“The results of this study affirm that the treatments for tetanus, using intramuscular equine antitoxin, which is a minimally-invasive treatment, is safe and effective. Compared to the invasive, complicated procedure of intrathecal injection, the result of this study shows the potential of intramuscular equine antitoxin in low and middle-income settings,” wrote Dr Lam Minh Yen, Senior Study Doctor at OUCRU and Dr Nguyen Van Hao, first author, Head of the Adult Intensive Care Unit at the Hospital for Tropical Diseases, Ho Chi Minh City, and Head of the Infectious Disease Department at the University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Ho Chi Minh City.

Two hundred and seventy-two adult patients with a clinical diagnosis of generalised tetanus admitted to the intensive care unit of the Hospital for Tropical Diseases were enrolled in this 3-year study.

“OUCRU and the Hospital for Tropical Diseases are, I think, unique in their ability to carry out these large clinical trials in tetanus – combining the clinical trial expertise and also clinical expertise in treating the patients who we hope will ultimately benefit from these type of studies,” shared Dr Louise Thwaites, Senior Clinical Research Fellow at OUCRU and Associate Professor in the Centre for Tropical Medicine and Global Health at the University of Oxford.

“This is an important study – one of the few clinical trials for a disease that continues to affect many people in low and middle-income countries each year. The trial shows that giving antitoxin (the main treatment for tetanus) by a spinal injection compared to the normal route (into the muscle) did not significantly improve patient disease severity or outcome.”

“The results are useful for doctors treating tetanus throughout the world, but especially in limited-resource settings, and show that a complicated and relatively expensive treatment is not necessary.”

The full story is available on the OUCRU website

Similar stories

Improving access to care for people in Vietnam impacted by Hepatitis C: dissemination workshop to share findings of OUCRU’s community-based participatory research

OUCRU and HCMC Hospital for Tropical Diseases host a one-day research dissemination workshop for policy, healthcare, community, and research stakeholders. The workshop is the culmination of an OUCRU project: “Community-based participatory research to promote engagement with underserved communities at risk of Hepatitis C virus in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam”.

The journey of dreams, improving engagement with underserved populations at risk for Hepatitis C in Vietnam.

OUCRU Public and Community Engagement team produced a video based on their project “Community-based participatory research to promote engagement with underserved communities at risk of Hepatitis C virus in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam”. This video was made by community members of the community-based participatory research to the project. The video is in Vietnamese with English subtitles

Watch our webinar - Radical cure of vivax malaria: can we do better?

The three presentations and expert discussion by Dr Rob Commons, Dr Alison Roth and Dr James Watson, chaired by Professor Sir Nicholas White (Mahidol Oxford Research Unit) and Dr Chau Nguyen Hoang (Oxford University Clinical Research Unit), are now available.

Multidisciplinary dengue forecasting project launches in Vietnam

DART (Dengue Advanced Readiness Tools), is a new project supported by Wellcome to use climate data to better predict and prepare for infectious diseases outbreaks.

OUCRU’s Photographer In Residence Featured In The Lancet’s Highlights 2022

Photographs have the power to inform and engage viewers. Earlier this year, The Lancet invited submissions for Highlights, the publication’s annual photography competition. Highlights 2022 featured 14 winning photographs telling stories from a wide variety of health-related topics that captured the world’s attention in 2022. One of the powerful images selected was from Pearl Gan, OUCRU’s Photographer in Residence.

Researchers call for antimicrobial resistance surveillance to be improved

The number of studies reporting antimicrobial resistance (AMR) data has increased in Africa, South and South East Asia according to new research in the International Journal of Infectious Diseases.